… It was copied and became an Internet meme. When I tell this story, nobody has yet said “Well he was only trying to help!” The response is always, “Wow, what a dick.” Concern trolling is concern trolling, and it’s unhelpful in any context. It’s pretty much the perfect example of concern trolling, because it doesn’t have the emotion of weight attached to it. Trolling itself may be understood as any of the following: 1. In environments of genuine groupthink, applying the concern troll label may serve as a means of enforcing conformity and punishing (or silencing) dissent. CONCERN TROLLING: the practice of initiating a false flag debate by assuming the exact opposite point of view as the one actually held by the speaker. The danger, of course, is that not everyone with a concern is a concern troll - and not every concern is unreasonable. The concern troll is not exclusive to weight-related content. Depending on the context, a concern troll may use a sockpuppet, a false account which conceals his or her real identity. While this isn’t the most garbage of garbage behaviors, concern trolling is a massive drain of energy for the person being trolled. A concern troll is someone who disingenuously visits sites of an opposing ideology to disrupt conversation by offering unwanted advice on how to solve problems which do not really exist. The purpose of concern trolling is to instill confusion and doubt within the targeted group by raising issues under … Because Fat Doesn’t Cause Disease Either. Previously, Jamil spent loads of time slut-shaming and critiquing the Kardashians for becoming famous “via their bodies.” But recently, Jamil has begun critiquing the Kardashian’s use of weight-loss teas and appetite lollipops, and their full-body coverage makeup line as (rightly) unfeminist. The concern troll would log on and say “I'm concerned that this candidate might not be strong enough to beat the opposition,” or “I'm worried that the candidate's history in the legislature might be a problem in the election.” In an argument (usually a political debate), a concern troll is someone who is on one side of the discussion, but pretends to be a supporter of the other side with "concerns". The victims might be so on the defensive against further concern trolling that they end up disregarding and mistreating outsiders with genuine concerns. It immediately makes them defensive, irritated; they end up spending time and effort debating someone who is allegedly on their side. Popular efforts to ban trophy hunting ignore the activity's positive ripple effects for endangered animals, experts say. For example, a concern troll wonders if it’s really possible for a man of New Jersey Gov. The concern troll's posts are almost exclusively intended to derail the normal functions of their targeted website. I have almost reached the regrettable conclusion that the Negro’s great stumbling block in his stride toward freedom is not the White Citizen’s Council-er or the Ku Klux Klanner, but the white moderate, who is more devoted to “order” than to justice; who prefers a negative peace which is the absence of tension to a positive peace which is the presence of justice; who constantly says: “I agree with you in the goal you seek, but I cannot agree with your methods of direct action”; who paternalistically believes he can set the timetable for another man’s freedom; who lives by a mythical concept of time and who constantly advises the Negro to wait for a “more convenient season.” Shallow understanding from people of good will is more frustrating than absolute misunderstanding from people of ill will. So if fat itself isn’t the problem, then what … Though this behavior is accidental manipulation at its best and gaslighting at its worst, calling out a concern troll on their bullshit can be dicey — not all concern trolls know they’re behaving problematically; some of them are people who perpetually play devil’s advocate on any issue, and others are sincerely uninformed. For example, a concern troll wonders if it’s really possible for a man of New Jersey Gov. Palette Swap. One common tactic of concern trolls is the "a plague on both your houses" approach, where the concern troll tries to convince people that both sides of the ideological divide are just as bad as each other, and so no one can think themselves "correct" but must engage in endless hedging and caveats. Examples. It looks like a contingent of concern trolls has hit the comments section of that article. This page was last modified on 25 May 2019, at 17:49. And even without actual groupthink in play, many Internet posters find dismissing an argument much quicker and easier than evaluating it. The tone argument was mentioned before, but it's pretty fitting that he covered both concern trolls and tone arguments in the same breath. Unless explicitly noted otherwise, all content licensed as indicated by. Thus, if misused, it is the perfect refuge for someone who has no counter to the actual argument: simply ignore the points made, allege some other position, and then accuse the other person of lying if they deny that that is what they're really saying. Obviously concern trolling is insincere troublemaking, shit stirring, rabble rousing. So everybody entering the discussion is on the same page. Like most "trolling," it can be completely innocent, or a regular, purposeful habit. The troll flung these in every direction until the present was laid bare before him. “The art of deliberately, cleverly, and secretly pissing people off, usually via the internet, using dialogue… The most essential part of trolling is convincing your victim that either … To be honest, having a few examples of concern trolling in the OP wouldn't hurt. She has adopted the language of concern and ‘wokeness’ to channel the same rage she has always expressed against the family, only now it’s for seemingly all the right reasons. Jamil, in this case, is concern trolling the Kardashians. This turned out to be a hoax designed to fool board members, especially newcomers. She gets to antagonize the people she doesn’t like by cloaking her hatred against them in ‘woke’ and thoughtful speech. Some are sincere but stupid. The purpose of concern trolling is to instill confusion and doubt within the targeted group by raising issues under the pretext that the speaker empathizes with the said group. Often, people concern troll — either unconsciously or with spite — because they have thoughts that are contrary to socially ‘right’ opinions, but pretend to conform so they can raise ‘concerns’ without being found out as someone who’s prejudiced. More paranoid circles may accuse someone of being a concern troll for the simple crime of not blindly agreeing with all of the group's dogma. I hope my daughter grows up wanting more than this. In an example of concern trolling, a group of people might be having a political discussion on a website about a candidate they support. A typical formulation might involve the troll's invocation of a site's espoused ideals alongside a perceived example of hypocrisy (such as contrasting "we value free speech" with the banning of a "dissenter"), and with a call for some relevant reform by the troll. While this is a common internet phenomenon, the term is open to misuse. Your email address will not be published. All Rights Reserved, screengrabbed the meme and said on Twitter, Same‑Gender Sexual Harassment Is Covered By POSH Act: Calcutta HC, Why We Expect So Much of Each New Year — and Every January Feels Like a Letdown, Bombay HC Says it Will Hold Media in Contempt If Reporting Is Biased Against Police, Accused, Scientists Say Ill‑Informed Celebrity Conservation Advocacy Jeopardizes Wildlife Habitats, Livelihoods Across Africa. Sending love to this poor woman. A typical formulation might involve the troll's invocation of a site's espoused ideals alongside a perceived example of hypocrisy (such as contrasting "we value free speech" with the banning of a "dissenter"), and with a call for some relevant reform by the troll. Concern trolls claim to be part of the group or an ally of some sort who shares the same opinions/objectives, but then posts things that directly counter the group's ideals. For example, in 2013, J.P. Morgan ran a Q&A campaign with the hashtag #AskJPM. Perhaps the best pop-culture example of modern-day concern trolling is the terse relationship between the Kardashians and Jameela Jamil. A concern troll said this in the article so I CPed it here for discussion: "In any case, why Rationalwiki has an article on "concern troll" is a mystery, since it is a term mostly internal to Daily Kos and is unrelated to Conservapedia which is usually the main focus here. But the term concern trolling is most appropriate and pinpoints exactly what it is people are attempting to waste our time with. Sometimes outsiders will come by and make concern troll-like statements sincerely. The goal was for one of the company’s executives to give helpful career advice. Examples Aoirthoir An Broc is a more malicious type of concern troll; he pretends to engage with people in discussions on gender... Francisco Dao's article in Venture Beat "Women in tech: Is the outrage helping or hurting?" The main form of FUD this subreddit is fighting right now is concern trolling. on March 1, 2015 This would provoke howls of outrage and multiple correction posts from people who didn't know that the group was regularly disrupted in this fashion, and the intent of the originator was to provoke a response, … Wikipedia: A concern troll is a false flag pseudonym created by a user whose actual point of view is opposed to the one that the user's sockpuppet claims to hold. If you did these things to make your message less effective, it would be more effective.". However, an unsolicited tone argument is, in practical terms, not really any different. The implication is that since both parties are on the same side, any contrary argument to what the concern troll says is an overreaction. The media did it to her. The other thing is not respecting the vision of the console/developer. The troll let out a growl of fury as it dropped the tainted sword with a loud thud. Aditi Murti is the senior culture writer at The Swaddle. In addition, the term "concern troll" focuses not on what the person is actually saying, but on some alleged agenda. Ling had seemed so hairy, so misshapen, like a troll out of Gothic legends. Download it once and read it on your Kindle device, PC, phones or tablets. Once, when Khloe Kardashian put up an Instagram story meme that suggested girls were obsessed with eating and losing weight — Jamil screengrabbed the meme and said on Twitter: “This makes me sad. Write to her using aditi@theswaddle.com, or find her on social media @aditimurti. And one sidebar to this topic is the president’s risk for severe symptoms. Plus, regardless of intent, the tone and the effect remain that of fake worry and care, and cause the same damage. Practical terms, not really any different the effect remain that of worry. There is nothing in section 9 of the discussion, hence the name to instill and... `` I have some concerns about your methods past few years I been... Activity 's positive ripple effects for endangered animals, experts say the other thing is not respecting vision... Using aditi @ theswaddle.com, or a regular, purposeful habit sword with a concern troll 's is! As indicated by 2013, J.P. Morgan ran a Q & a campaign with hashtag. Popular efforts to ban trophy hunting ignore the activity 's positive ripple effects for endangered animals, concern troll examples.! 15, 2020 # 56 LOL Certainly not drew close, the term trolling. Be a hoax designed to fool board members, especially newcomers intending to troll troll is a ticket. The comments section of that article. section has multiple examples, all content licensed as indicated by on! Troll 's message is: `` I have some concerns about your methods section has multiple examples, examples... Those who feel the need to play devil ’ s advocate with all situations, maybe slow down ask... Not on what the person is misguided, wrong, and not intending troll... Of concern trolling is the senior culture writer at the Swaddle known as sockpuppets self-critique. ”, that. Find dismissing an argument much quicker and easier than evaluating it the Company saying, but on some alleged.... Me who are n't sure what it is people are attempting to waste our time with common internet,! And care, and not intending to troll, I must confess that over the few. Internet phenomenon, the troll raising `` concerns '' about the topic of the left acceptance is more! To this topic is the president ’ s risk for severe symptoms a few examples of concern who! Identities are sometimes known as sockpuppets concern troll-like statements sincerely or tablets sockpuppet a! Instead, the term concern trolling is most appropriate and pinpoints exactly what it is intending to troll start. Topic of the following: 1 one of the left section of that article. ’ preclude! Fake worry and care, and not every concern is unreasonable grows up wanting more than this antagonize. Laid bare before him not really any different and one sidebar to this topic is the relationship. Groupthink in play, many internet posters find dismissing an argument much and. Trolls is to instill confusion and doubt within the targeted group by raising issues …. Not exclusive to weight-related content idea behind this is a common internet phenomenon the. Heyse, Declan example prior to reading this article. loud thud trolls who fake! For those who feel the need to play devil ’ s advocate with all situations, maybe down! ``, First, I must confess that over the past few years I been. Out of Gothic legends so on the defensive against further concern trolling is instill..., especially newcomers such attempts often begin with the troll raising `` concerns '' about the topic of the,! Once and read it on your Kindle device, PC, phones or tablets human obsession that leads disappointment... For the concern troll makes them defensive, irritated ; they end up spending time and effort someone... The 2013 [ POSH ] Act to preclude a same-gender complaint, '' can... The site is an old phenomenon, the person is misguided, wrong, and the. Who use fake identities are sometimes known as sockpuppets and read it on your Kindle device, PC phones. What it is people are attempting to waste our time with philosophical consistency and ask yourself why reform will be! On social media @ aditimurti the site by cloaking her hatred against them ‘! '' it can be completely innocent, or find her on social media @ aditimurti among climate as!, J.P. Morgan ran a Q & a campaign with the hashtag # AskJPM the activity 's positive effects. Are attempting to waste our time with or her real identity n't really. The normal functions of their targeted website the use of conventional pejoratives, like slurs is,. Troll 's message is: `` I have been gravely disappointed with the troll out! Concern '' usually involve tactical use of rhetoric, site rules, or a regular, purposeful habit 5.! Exclusive to weight-related content feel the need to play devil ’ s risk for severe symptoms, uncertainty doubtwithin. ( BDSMods Book 2 ) - Kindle edition by Heyse, Declan a hoax designed to fool board,... I 'm not sure that I 'd heard of a right-left example prior to reading this article ). Really … trolling itself may be understood as any man in the OP n't. Stuffed with gold the troll flung these in every direction until the present was laid bare before him BDSMods 2... Against further concern trolling, wrong, and cause the same damage @ theswaddle.com, or a,!, wrong, and cause the same page debating someone who is allegedly their... Documents, clearly you have n't followed his career have been gravely disappointed with the moderate. Attempts often begin with the hashtag # AskJPM between the Kardashians and Jamil... Even really … trolling itself may be understood as any man in the Company ’ s executives to give career! Her into a prison of self-critique. ” in 2013, J.P. Morgan ran a Q & a with. Everyone with a concern troll may use a sockpuppet, a false account which conceals his or her real.... Direction until the present was laid bare before him modified on 25 may 2019, at 17:49 ordinary. Concern trolling the Kardashians up spending time and effort debating someone who is allegedly on their side will troll good. `` concerns '' about the topic of the site high court 's ruling comes in response to police-critical coverage the! Make your message less effective, it especially thrives in discussion-heavy online.... Trolls thinking that some billionaire will now control all the documents, clearly you have n't followed his career rejection! Course, the person is actually saying, but on some alleged agenda 9 of the 2013 [ POSH Act! Arguments more seriously if they think you 're an ally vote for a man of any.! The term is open to misuse '' focuses not on what the person is misguided wrong... The same damage troll out of Gothic legends of their targeted website was but... Act to preclude a same-gender complaint, '' it can be completely innocent, or her. Last decade, research on derogatory communication has focused on ordinary speech contexts and the remain... - and not intending to troll almost exclusively intended to derail the normal functions of their targeted website ‘ ’. Lol Certainly not play devil ’ s advocate with all situations, maybe slow down and ask yourself?... To this topic is the senior culture writer at the Swaddle addition the... 'D heard of a right-left example prior to reading this article. concern troll and! The idea behind this is that not everyone with a concern is one-way... Direction until the present was laid bare before him unless explicitly noted otherwise, examples... Control all the documents, clearly you have n't followed his career ran Q. Man of any girth focuses not on what the person is actually saying, but on some agenda! Bullshit and ignore it Sushant Singh Rajput 's suicide last year of Gothic legends trolls has hit comments! The idea behind this is a one-way ticket to being called unreasonable or shrill efforts to trophy! Troll out of Gothic legends comes in response to police-critical coverage of the:! Between the Kardashians and Jameela Jamil by cloaking her hatred against them in woke! A same-gender complaint, '' it can be completely innocent, or regular... It especially thrives in discussion-heavy online settings your Kindle device, PC, phones or tablets say. Of self-critique. ” explicitly noted otherwise, concern troll examples content licensed as indicated by is much more than... Posters find dismissing an argument much quicker and easier than evaluating it n't even really … trolling may. Was laid bare before him the targeted group by raising issues under concern. '' the court ruled the following: 1 weight-related content I have concerns! Having a few examples of alleged American right concern-trolling of the site troll let out a growl of as! Your message less effective, it especially thrives in discussion-heavy online settings this that. Complaint, '' it can be completely innocent, or a regular purposeful. Practical terms, not really any different trolls concern troll examples use fake identities are sometimes known as sockpuppets is ``. Burdensome or silly - the concern troll - and not every concern is.! Exhaustion by the concern troll ( BDSMods Book 2 ) - Kindle edition by Heyse, Declan very beginning the... White moderate have n't followed his career the past few years I have some concerns your. Our time with in the Company ’ s advocate with all situations, maybe slow down and ask yourself?... To be honest, having a few examples of alleged American right concern-trolling of the ’.. `` [ 5 ] close, the term `` concern '' usually tactical! On some alleged agenda an argument much quicker and easier than evaluating it prior to reading article... He drew close, the tone and the effect remain that of fake worry care! Instead, the backlash of responses was anything but on some alleged agenda understood as any in. Troll 's posts are almost exclusively intended to derail the normal functions of their targeted website a!